Top 10 stocks. Once a month. Expert picks, straight to your inbox.See the newsletter
Etsy logo

Etsy

ETSY
$88.29
▲ +69%since Benson's first pick

Market price data through November 12, 2026.

Performance

Nov 2021 – Nov 2026

Benson's first pick
$20$119$218$317Nov 2021Feb 2023May 2024Aug 2025Nov 2026Benson picked · $52.58
Model signal
Buy
What Benson's model currently says about this stock.
Benson rating
3.6 / 5
Benson's overall conviction in this stock right now.
Risk
High risk
How bumpy the ride tends to be with this stock.

Track record

How this pick has done since Benson first called it.

Benson Return
+69%
How much this stock is up since Benson first picked it — measured from the price at the time of that first pick, not from today.
First pick price
~$52
Roughly what one share cost when Benson first picked this stock. This is the starting line for the Benson Return.
Tracking since
September 2024
The month this stock first became a Benson pick.
Tracking duration
26 months
How long Benson has been tracking this pick.

About Etsy

Etsy runs the go-to online marketplace for handmade, vintage, and one-of-a-kind goods. Think custom gifts, indie jewelry, and home decor you cannot find on Amazon. It connects 86.5 million shoppers with 5.6 million mostly tiny businesses, and you can now buy those items right inside ChatGPT, Google, and Microsoft Copilot.

The case for and against

Both sides of the story, in plain English.

Bull case
  • Growth Is Back

    After two years of shrinking sales, the core Etsy marketplace grew again in the holiday quarter. Shoppers spent 3.29 billion dollars, up 0.1 percent. It is a small gain, but the company expects 2.38 to 2.43 billion dollars in sales in the first quarter of 2026 and growth in every quarter of the year, while shopping on the Etsy app jumped 6.6 percent and now makes up about 46 percent of everything sold.

  • Bigger Slice

    Etsy keeps more of every sale than it used to. Its cut rose to 24.5 percent from 22.8 percent a year ago, mostly because sellers are buying more ads. That pushed revenue up 6.6 percent to 881.6 million dollars, and Etsy expects its cut to reach about 25.5 percent in early 2026, with 1.8 billion dollars in cash, 133 million dollars of its own stock bought back in three months, and 1.2 billion dollars coming from selling Depop to eBay.

Bear case
  • Shrinking Crowd

    Fewer people are shopping on Etsy than a year ago. Active buyers fell 3.4 percent to 86.5 million, sellers slipped 1.5 percent to 5.6 million, and the average shopper now spends 121 dollars a year, down 0.5 percent. Etsy did win or win back 17.2 million buyers this quarter, but taking a bigger cut only works for so long if the crowd keeps thinning.

  • Profit Squeeze

    Profits went the wrong way in 2025. Full year net income fell 46.3 percent to 163 million dollars, as costs rose 8.8 percent while revenue grew just 2.7 percent. Etsy is also selling Depop, a business whose sales grew 37 percent last quarter, which leaves a slow-growing core marketplace to carry the whole story.

How to read this page

This automated research summary uses Financial Modeling Prep market data through 2026-11-12. Model signals, scores, and risk labels can change and may be incomplete or wrong.

Want Benson to watch ETSY for you?

Get the app to follow every Benson pick live — and let Benson do the research for you.